Unveiling the 9 Hidden Costs of Buying a Short-Term Rental

Kinzie Brink
July 8, 2024
5 min read

Unveiling the 9 Hidden Costs of Buying a Short-Term Rental

Investing in the short-term rental market can be an exciting adventure with the promise of profitability and a steady income stream. However, beyond the upfront costs and apparent expenses, there lies a field of hidden fees and financial considerations that every prospective buyer should carefully navigate. In this comprehensive guide, we explore the often-overlooked costs associated with purchasing a short-term rental home, ensuring you are well-prepared to make informed financial decisions and start your new business on the right foot.

1. Purchase Price and Down Payment

The initial cost of acquiring a property is typically the most obvious expense. However, the number on the “for sale” sign is not the only consideration when purchasing a new property. Depending on where you get your home loan from, you may have to pay out of pocket for fees such as applications, mortgage assumptions, credit reporting, discount points, origination, and escrow. Down payments (usually a percentage of the purchase price) are also a significant upfront cost that impacts your financing options and cash flow. While a 20% down payment may be the traditional recommendation, many people today put a much lower percentage down due to current housing market rates. Buyers should also budget for closing costs, which can include appraisal fees, title insurance, legal fees, and third-party costs among others.

2. Renovation and Furnishing

Preparing a property for short-term rental often requires renovations and furnishing beyond what's needed for personal use. Upgrades such as modern kitchens, stylish bathrooms, and comfortable furnishings can attract higher-paying guests but come with a high price tag. Renovation costs can escalate quickly, especially if structural changes or extensive remodeling are necessary. Furnishing expenses include not only furniture but also linens, kitchenware, decor, and amenities like WiFi routers and entertainment systems. However, the more amenities you have to offer your guests, the more they may be willing to pay.

3. Property Taxes and Insurance

Property taxes vary significantly by location and property value. They are a yearly obligation that should be factored into your annual operating budget. Furthermore, while many third-party rental companies such as Airbnb or VRBO offer free insurance to their hosts, it is often extremely limited, and most owners prefer to seek other short-term rental insurance. Insurance for short-term rental properties differs from standard homeowners' insurance and tends to be more expensive due to increased liability risks associated with frequent guest turnover. Sometimes called home-sharing insurance, it can sometimes be sold as an add-on to your existing homeowner’s insurance policy or it can be bought separately as a stand-alone policy. Additional coverage for theft, property damage, and loss of rental income due to unforeseen circumstances is advisable but adds to your operating costs.

4. Utilities and Maintenance

Utilities such as electricity, water, heating, and cooling are recurring expenses that can fluctuate based on occupancy rates and guest usage. Depending on how booked your rental property is, your monthly utilities may cost more than a typical house due to heavy use and guests regularly coming and going. Property management fees, whether paid to a professional service or self-managed, cover tasks like guest communication, housekeeping, and maintenance. Routine upkeep, repairs, and occasional major maintenance projects (like roof repairs or HVAC replacements) are inevitable costs that can impact your profitability if not properly budgeted for. When renting properties, it’s best to always keep an emergency fund for any emergency repairs or last-minute fixes that can prove costly.

5. Marketing and Advertising

Effective marketing is essential for maximizing your property's occupancy and revenue potential. Listing on short-term rental platforms, hiring a professional photographer, creating virtual tours, and designing targeted advertising campaigns can all help contribute to attracting guests, but they also cost money. It can also be worth it to invest in search engine optimization (SEO), social media marketing, and online reservation systems that can drive bookings and improve the overall guest experience. Advertising can also be one of the most complicated and frustrating aspects to owning a short-term rental and many owners choose to hire a third-party company to take over their marketing for them. While many owners feel that doing so can significantly increase their guest bookings, hiring a marketing company often means monthly recurring fees.

6. Regulatory Compliance and Permits

Many cities and municipalities have specific regulations governing short-term rentals. These may include licensing fees, occupancy taxes, safety inspections, and zoning restrictions. Failing to comply with local regulations can lead to fines or legal consequences, making it crucial to research and budget for any necessary permits or compliance measures. Make sure to contact your local city hall or schedule an appointment with a real estate agent who can discuss the specific fees associated with your area.

7. Unexpected Vacancies and Income Variability

The income from short-term rentals can fluctuate seasonally. Depending on your area, you may find that specific seasons or months are often lacking when it comes to guest reservations. There can also be other external factors like economic downturns, natural disasters, or changes in travel trends that can impact bookings. Vacancy periods between bookings or unexpected cancellations can disrupt cash flow and affect your ability to cover mortgage payments and operating expenses. Maintaining a financial cushion to weather these fluctuations is mandatory for long-term sustainability.

8. Capital Gains Taxes

While rental income can provide a steady revenue stream, it's important to consider the tax implications. Capital gains taxes affect any realized profit earned from capital assets, such as rental properties. If you have owned your short-term rental for less than a year, you will most likely fall under the short-term capital gains tax and be taxed at a rate similar to regular income, which is typically between 10% and 37% depending on your earnings. However, after owning your rental for more than one year, you will fall under the long-term capital gains tax and be charged 0%, 15%, or 20% depending on your taxable income. When purchasing a new rental property, it’s always best to speak to a tax advisor and get help optimizing your tax strategy while also ensuring compliance with tax laws.

9. HOA Fees and Community Assessments

Properties located within homeowners’ associations (HOAs) or community associations often require membership dues and special assessments for community upkeep and amenities. These fees can vary widely and should be factored into your budget, as they directly impact your net rental income. HOAs can also require homes to follow certain regulations or aesthetic guidelines, such as paint colors, mailbox requirements, or fencing restrictions. Depending on how well the previous owner followed HOA rules, your new rental may come with an upfront cost to update the property and ensure it complies with any requirements.  

Conclusion

Investing in the short-term rental market can be a lucrative and rewarding decision, but it also requires a thorough understanding of the hidden costs and financial considerations involved. When owners meticulously plan for expenses, disasters, and accidents, they ensure their ability to bounce back from financial strains and continue making a profit. From renovations to ongoing maintenance to taxes and fees, there are a lot of extra costs that come with owning a rental home that many people don’t consider. However, a proactive approach and a good budgeting strategy will set you on the right path to navigating the complexities of the short-term rental market successfully.

Share this post